Carthage Mutual Insurance Co. Added by vervocity 0 reviews Listed in Insurance 527 North Madison St , Carthage, IL 62321 217-357-3961 Add to Favorites Contact Listing OwnerContact the Listing OwnerTo inquire about this listing, complete the form below to send a message to the listing owner.Name *Email *Phone NumberWebsiteMessage * Updated: Sep 29, 2015 Overview Reviews Add Your Review Please login or register to add your review.